|
Post by phdsims on Nov 30, 2008 18:25:42 GMT -4
ok and ut have the same record....
ut beat ok at a NEUTRAL location....and ok is rated higher in the BCS....
in what world does that make sense....
|
|
|
Post by Steve on Nov 30, 2008 18:55:45 GMT -4
That's pathetic...even though I believe Oklahoma is a better team...that doesn't mean you can jump them because they're better...it really doesn't matter, but the BCS just doesn't want you to play it on the field. Man, that's awful.
|
|
|
Post by Seattle Slough on Nov 30, 2008 19:44:28 GMT -4
Going to get worse from here guys. Bama and florida play in the sec championship. If florida beat bama, will bama stay in the top two? highly doubt it, but they would still only have one loss on their belt and some team that won't play a conference title game will end up in the National title game without having to do anything.
I hate the BCS, worst fucking end of the season system of all time.
So many top good college teams this year and you won't get to see them battle it out, sad, sad, sad.
|
|
|
Post by Beast Mode (lilsims) on Dec 1, 2008 13:10:10 GMT -4
tech beats texas and has one loss, but not even in the top 8 because the one loss ( to the number 2 rated team) came at the end of the season. imo tech, texas, ou, florida, bama are the top 5 teams, yet we will never know whose the best team. bcs is all screwed up
|
|
|
Post by J-Sav on Dec 1, 2008 13:40:29 GMT -4
I HATE THE BCS!
Alot more games would have more meaning if you had an 8 team playoff. And would be so sick to have an 8 team playoff right now with all the great teams in the top 8.
|
|
|
Post by BeastModeCowboy on Dec 1, 2008 16:58:09 GMT -4
even if they had a playoff system there would still be team bitching about not making it, I think the BCS has it is issues but its a lot better than a playoff because non BCS team would really be fucked in a playoff system because college football is about the money and non BCS schools don't bring enough money to the table to put them into a playoff system....also unlike college basketball there is no way that non bcs school could survive having to play the big time schools they would need to be in the top 8 on a regular basis alone with the thought a lot of the D2 schools who budgets come from playing the Major schools on the road would die because you would force schools to no longer play the cup cakes of the world. The way things are now every game counts for something, i would hate to see my hogs in a game against any team that is resting their players because they have made it into the playoffs......just like the nfl games u pay 100 bucks for a tickets and your favorite player isn't playing......
|
|
|
Post by Beast Mode (lilsims) on Dec 1, 2008 17:52:40 GMT -4
i would like to see the winners of the top two bowls play in a final deciding game. im not for a playoff, but instead i would want an extra game for the winners of the top two bcs bowls. that way atleast 1-4 gets a title shot. people will still feel shafted, but it also gives both sides what they want
|
|
|
Post by rogworld1991 on Dec 1, 2008 18:18:57 GMT -4
even if they had a playoff system there would still be team bitching about not making it, I think the BCS has it is issues but its a lot better than a playoff because non BCS team would really be fucked in a playoff system because college football is about the money and non BCS schools don't bring enough money to the table to put them into a playoff system....also unlike college basketball there is no way that non bcs school could survive having to play the big time schools they would need to be in the top 8 on a regular basis alone with the thought a lot of the D2 schools who budgets come from playing the Major schools on the road would die because you would force schools to no longer play the cup cakes of the world. The way things are now every game counts for something, i would hate to see my hogs in a game against any team that is resting their players because they have made it into the playoffs......just like the nfl games u pay 100 bucks for a tickets and your favorite player isn't playing...... Lets examine the top 12 right now... 1. Alabama 2. Oklahoma 3. Texas 4. Florida 5. USC 6. Utah7. Texas Tech 8. Penn State 9. Boise State10. Ohio State 11. TCU 12. Ball StateThere is 4 teams in the top 12, all from lower level confrences, all considered non BCS schools.... i think a playoff wouldn't eliminate non BCS schools... Now as far as BCS it should be 1. Alabama 2. Texas 3. Oklahoma 4. Florida 5. Texas Tech 6. Utah 7. USC 8. Boise State 9. Penn State 10. TCU 11. Ball State 12. Ohio State Now as far as OT comments are concerned, if Florida wins and Oklahoma wins, then Florida will play Oklahoma in the Championship... so both teams won there confrence championship.... Only way a non champ gets to the BSC is if Oklahoma loses.. then it comes down to USC or Texas... USC shouldn't get it, but they have a good point that their loss isn't that bad right now, because OSU is a good team, but i don't think they have beef over Texas... except they won their conference. Suggestion: Winner of EVERY Conference, all 11... then have 5 At large bids to make an 16 game playoff.... The at large bids should be selected by a committee, similar to the College Baskteball... but only 5 teams. This case it still would be Nulled because there is a 3 way tie for the Big 12 SOUTH, not the conference, the south.. thoughts?
|
|
|
Post by Steve on Dec 2, 2008 20:30:32 GMT -4
Penn State should be ahead of USC, Utah, and Boise State...it's a sham that they aren't. USC lost to Oregon State and we blew them out like they were a non BCS team. And Utah and Boise State can't seriously believe that they're on the same level as us. USC shouldn't be considered for the National Title game if Oklahoma lost.
|
|
|
Post by rogworld1991 on Dec 3, 2008 18:00:17 GMT -4
i agree USC shouldn't be considered, the thing with Utah is that they have several good wins, i mean BYU was suppose to crack the top 5 this season... and TCU is always good, thats a tough team to beat.
|
|